Ranked: Newcastle United’s Premier League Goalkeepers

Photo by Kelly McClay, CC by 2.0

Since the Premier League began in 1992, Newcastle United have only had two stints outside of the top-flight, returning as second-tier champions each time. In that period, numerous goalkeepers have had the honour of defending the Toon’s goal. Here’s our ranking of every goalkeeper to play in the Premier League for the Newcastle, from worst to best.

13. John Karelse

John Karelse’s Newcastle career was so brief that little video evidence exists of his time as keeper for the black and whites. The Dutchman was signed for £900K by fellow-countryman Ruud Gullit, but failed to make a good first impression when he replaced the injured Steve Harper for his debut against Southampton.

Karelse conceded four in that game and three in the next before being dropped, and he would only appear in one more Premier League game when Sir Bobby Robson took over from Gullit.

12. Jak Alnwick

It’s probably fair to say that for Jak Alnwick, his brief spell between the posts for Newcastle came a little too early in his career. Aged just 21 when he was called upon to deputise for the injured Tim Krul, Alnwick found himself out of his depth, conceding 14 goals in his six Premier League appearances.

Jak struggled to make his presence felt under high balls and was sent to Preston on a free at the end of the 2015 season, although he did go on to enjoy something of a late-career renaissance for St Mirren in the Scottish Premiership.

11. Mike Hooper

Mike Hooper spent the majority of his career at Liverpool, where he acted as back-up to Bruce Grobbelaar and David James. He arrived at Newcastle at the age of 29, but again would go on to be used mainly from the bench behind Pavel Srnicek and Shaka Hislop in the three years he spent with The Magpies from 1993 to ’96.

The fact that Hooper was at one stage loaned out to bitter rivals Sunderland underlines the point that he was never likely to make a breakthrough at Newcastle. His fate at the club was sealed when cameras caught him laughing on the subs bench when Newcastle conceded a goal, and he would be released by the club, never to play professional football again.

10. Tommy Wright

The stats are somewhat deceiving when it comes to Northern Irish international Tommy Wright. Although he only made three appearances in the Premier League era, he played a total of more than 100 senior matches for Newcastle, claiming the number one spot in the 1988/89 season.

Wright performed particularly well for The Toon in the second tier in 1992/93 before eventually losing his place to Pavel Srnicek. Apologies to Newcastle fans (and Tommy) for the choice of video, but there was slim pickings to choose from, and Wright was centrally involved in one of the most controversial moments of this game.

9. Rob Elliot

When Rob Elliot signed for Newcastle on a five-year deal in 2011, he publicly stated his intention to become the club’s number one keeper. His 55 Premier League appearances over nine years with the club is evidence that he never quite managed to achieve that particular ambition.

Tim Krul, Karl Darlow and later Martin Dubrovka were all above him in the pecking order, and despite the fact that Elliot had undoubted talent and was even capped four times by the Republic of Ireland, he remained a substitute for the majority of his time with Newcastle.

8. Karl Darlow

Northampton-born Darlow performed creditably in the 2020/21 season when called upon to deputise for the injured Martin Dubravka. His 25 matches between the sticks were for the most part a success, although when Dubravka returned to fitness he was soon restored to the number one spot for the Geordies.

Darlow failed to reclaim the spot at Newcastle and left the club at the end of the 2022/23 season.

7. Shaka Hislop

Shaka Hislop signed for Newcastle in 1995 and he would go on to play for the club for three years, amassing 53 Premier League appearances in that time. Despite being popular with both the fans and his teammates, Hislop never really managed to make the position his own in the face of stiff competition from Pavel Srnicek and Shay Given.

An imposing figure between the sticks, Shaka was known for his reflexive shot-stopping, and these days he works as a TV pundit for ESPN.

6. Martin Dubravka

Slovak net-minder Dubravka initially joined Newcastle on loan in January 2018, but impressed so much in his debut season that a permanent move was agreed.

In the 2018/19 season Dubravka was rated the top goalkeeper in the Premier League by the influential FourFourTwo magazine, and had several impressive seasons with Newcastle.

After a brief competition with Darlow for the number one spot, Dubravka reclaimed the position, only to lose it to Nick Pope in the 2022/23 season.

5. Tim Krul

Tim Krul made a fantastic first impression on his debut for Newcastle when, aged just 18, he pulled off a string of high-quality saves in the 2006 UEFA Cup tie with Palermo. Krul would go on to play for the club for 12 years, enjoying a number of successful seasons when his shot-stopping ability garnered valuable points for Newcastle.

As the years passed he struggled with injuries, and he left the club in 2007 – aged 29 – and spent a decade on loan to various different clubs. Finally a transfer to Norwich saw a return to the form of old, and he was named that team’s Player of the Season for the 2019-20 campaign.

4. Steve Harper

The 88 Premier League appearances by Steve Harper simply do not do justice to his status as a legendary Newcastle player. Harper is the longest-serving player in Newcastle’s history, his 20-year career spanning 1993 to 2013. Although a fan favourite, Harper spent the majority of his Newcastle career as a back up to Srnicek, Hislop and Shay Given.

For a period under manager Ruud Gullit Harper looked like he had taken the number 1 jersey from Given, but when Gullit left the club Steve returned to bench-warming duties. Harper finally got his breakthrough when Given left the club for Man City, and he played 50 consecutive matches in the seasons that followed, cementing his legacy as an all-time Newcastle favourite.

3. Pavel Srnicek

Tragically, Pavel Srnicek’s life was taken far too early when he suffered a cardiac arrest during a run at the age of just 47. He is remembered fondly by all Newcastle fans as well as those who shared the pitch with him during his footballing career.

Srnicek played for Newcastle from 1991 to ’98, and even made a season-long return at the age of 38 to cover the position when injuries struck the trio of keepers with the club at the time. The Czech international was posthumously inducted into the NUFC Hall of Fame, and he will forever be remembered as a club legend.

2. Nick Pope

Battle hardened by six Premier League seasons at Burnley, Nick Pope joined Newcastle United in the 2022/23 season for a £10 million fee. Since then, the England international has been a hit at St. James Park. The shot-stopper has also been in the Golden Gloves race and also led the Tyneside outfit to the Champions League.

Pope has already recorded 26 clean sheets in 76 Premier League appearances and is on track to set the record for the most clean sheets by a Newcastle United goalkeeper in their first 100 matches.

1.Shay Given

There can be little question as to who takes the honour of being called Newcastle’s top keeper in the Premier League era. Donegal native Shay Given made more than twice as many appearances as any other goalkeeper since ’93, and his shot-stopping abilities and command of his area have him top of our list. Although small in stature for a keeper, Given saw off challenges from Harper, Srnicek and Hislop to make the number one shirt his own.

Shay spent the best years of his career at Newcastle, enjoying a fruitful 12 years with the club which included Champions League nights and cup finals among them, cementing his position as best NUFC keeper since the Premier League era began.